Thursday, October 24, 2013

Chayay Sarah חיי שרה – Peace with Ishmael

In parshas Chayay Sarah, Yitzchak is twice to be found at Be'er L'chai Rowee באר לחי ראי. The phrase can be difficult to translate. Be'er באר is a well. Chai חי means life, but in this context it is referring to the holy One, blessed be He, who is the source of all life. Rowee ראי is a gerund from the word "see" expressed in a possessive form, so to speak my watcher.

Ein Avdat reputed site of Be'er L'chai Rowee
The name of the place is coined by Hagar in parshas Lech L'cha when she is running away from her mistress, Sarah emanu. Hagar is pregnant by Avraham who has taken her as a second wife. Hagar errs by treating Avraham's prime wife, Sarah, lightly. When Sarah abuses her, she flees. On the road to Egypt the angel of Hashem appears to Hagar and tells her to return to Sarah and submit to her afflictions. G-d continues that she is going to give birth to a son. Because G-d has heard her prayer, he is to be namedYishma-el (ישמעאל), literally the Almighty will hear,. The boy will be a wild man who will father a large nation. He will have his hand in everybody's affairs and everybody will have a hand in his (see Bereshis 16:7–14).

Hagar names the place after her vision. Rashi explains Hagar's perception was that of a G-d that sees everything, but nobody sees Him. He specifically sees the insults of the afflicted and, is to be found not only in the abode of the righteous but even in remote places as well. The Sforno explains that this was the place where Hagar really prayed. He then brings Chazal that all of the gates are closed except for the gate of the distressed. The Ibn Ezra explains the word life as meaning that there would be another year of life and adds that the Ishmaelites had an annual celebration at this well.

In parshas Chayay Sarah the well is first mentioned as the place where Yitzchak went out to contemplate or to pray (Hebrew (לשוח (Bereshis 24:62). Rashi comments that the reason he went to Be'er L'chai Rowee was to bring Hagar back to Avraham. The Sforno explains that this was the place where Yitzchak meandered off the road to pour out his thoughts before Hashem. It is in Be'er L'chai Rowee that Yitzchak is consoled for the loss of his mother and finds his wife.

The second time Be'er L'chai Rowee is mentioned in this parsha is as the place where G-d appeared to Yitzchak and blessed him after the death of Avraham. Yitzchak subsequently decides to dwell in that area (Bereshis 25:11). Concerning the death of Avraham the Chumash recounts that he was buried by Yitzchak and Yishmael, specifically placing Yitzchak first (Bereshis 25:9). Rashi explains that from this we see that Yishmael repented. It also hints that he recognized Yitzchak as the legitimate heir to Avraham's mission. However Yishmael is still called Avraham's son and the sons of the concubines are not mentioned.

The parsha ends with the passing away of Yishmael (see Genesis 25:17) saying that he perished (ויגוע). Rashi comments that this word is used to describe the death of the righteous. The parsha also mentions Yishmael's age in the same style that was used for Sarah and Avraham. The Rambam explains this is the way of numbering the years of the righteous. He continues that it is used in connection with Yishmael to say that he really did change his ways and died a righteous man.

The Rambam in Guide for the Perplexed discusses Eastern and Western ways of thinking towards religion. In regards to the east he uses the word Mohammedans. Their approach is essentially introspection until it reveals the soul. They view G-d as close and see the hand of G-d directly controlling the world down to the finest details. The western approach is seeing G-d through observation of the environment and the supernal wisdom in the natural sciences.

When the Mohammedans err it is to say that G-d's providence reaches to the point that everything is done because G-d desires it and that human beings in fact have no free will. The error of the west tends to be the opposite in that it says that a man has complete control over his destiny and that G-d's providence is distant and scant. It seems that the East desires a benevolent society rooted in religion and the west desires material well being.

The Rambam analyzes the role of the Jews in this paradigm. The task of the Jews is to reconcile these two positions and provide a conduit through which the knowledge of one side flows to the other. In addition they are to add depth to this synthesis and relate it to Scripture.

The Arabs and the Jews both have intrinsic belief in G-d. However these feelings are stronger among the Ishmaelites and more greatly revealed. A Jew is more likely to be a lost soul. The message of Ishmael to Yitzchak at Be'er L'chai Rowee is that a person can be a thief and a savage in the wilderness but even so G-d can still be with him. In addition even from this state a person can return to the house of Avraham and die a tsadik.






To view on YouTube click:   http://youtu.be/TbySMiEGLeo
El Adon אל אדון sung at 10:46; Link to lyrics in Hebrew and English:


תרגום לעברית              
http://dyschreiber.blogspot.com/2013/10/41.html


No comments:

Post a Comment