Wednesday, April 6, 2016

Tazria \ Hodesh - In Harmony with Nature

The Shabbos before the month of Nissan is called “Shabbos HaHodesh”, literally Shabbos of the month. Every Shabbos that falls immediately before the start of a new month is called Shabbos Mevarchim (שַׁבַּת מְבָרְכִים). Mevarchim is the language of blessing or greeting in this case the incoming month.

The new moon that ushers in Nissan has special status, because the exodus from Egypt occurred during this month. Because of the importance of this momentous occasion the Holy One Blessed be He commanded the nation of Israel to reckon it as the head of all the months and, the first of the months of the year (see Exodus 12:2). The Mishna poskins (from the Hebrew פסק to establish, deem, or rule) that the Jews should include the section of the Chumash, which contains this commandment, as part of the normal reading of the Torah during morning service (Megillah 4:2). The Mishna Brura expounds on this saying, this is not the fundamental sanctification [of the new month]. Rather the sanctification is in essence at the time the new moon is seen, after which the new month is declared by the Sanhedrin. Therefore this reading from the Torah is only a rabbinic obligation (see section 585a).

The Mishna in fact mentions four “new years”. The first of Nissan is the new year for kings and holidays. The first of Elul is the new year for the tithing of cattle. The first of Tishre is the new year for years. And fifteenth of Shvat is the new year for trees (see Mishna Rosh Hashana 1:1).

This Mishna is the source of a debate in the Gemara (Rosh Hashana 10b-11a). “Rabbi Eliezer teaches in Tishri the world was created . . . on New Year’s the bondage of our ancestors in Egypt ceased; in Nisan they were redeemed and in Tishre they will be redeemed in the time to come. Rabbi Yehoshua teaches in Nisan the world was created . . . on Rosh Hashana the bondage of our ancestors ceased in Egypt; in Nisan they were redeemed and in Nisan they will be redeemed in time to come”.

Both bring scriptural and logical proofs. Rabbi Yehoshua claims that the trees at the time of creation were like the budding trees of spring. Rabbi Eliezer claims that the trees at the time of creation were like the fruited trees of fall. The Gemara brings an oblique scriptural hint that the trees were created in the fullest of their glory, thereby fixing the doctrine like Rabbi Eliezer.

All of this suggests that the first of Tishre is the first day of fall and the first of Nissan is the first day of spring. At the time of the creation this was most likely so and, from time to time it actually happens that way. This is because the Jewish calendar is only approximately synchronized with the tropical year. The Torah is not meticulous about precisely matching the date with the equinoxes. It requires only that Passover fall sometime in the spring and that Succos fall sometime in the autumn. It comes out that every two or three years an additional month is added.

Rosh Hashana, falling on the first of Tishre, is associated the tropical year and nature. On the other hand the lunar calendar is associated with miracles because of the miracles of Pesach which falls in Nissan. From a natural standpoint the tropical calendar very precisely standardizes the dates of the solstice and the times of the daily sunrise and sunset. As a result it is very helpful in determining the times to plant and harvest. The Jewish calendar is useful for this, but with its one month variations, the tropical calendar is better. The Jewish calendar accurately tells you how much moonlight there will be on a given date, which was very helpful before street lights. The calendar established by Julius Caesar makes no attempt to be synchronized with the moon.

In fact the Julian calendar requires periodic adjustment. Once every four years a leap day is added to keep it accurate. However, this was not adequate and by the year 1582 CE the spring equinox fell on March 31, and not March 21. To remedy the situation Pope Gregory struck ten days from the calendar plus said the leap day should be omitted once every hundred years. However every 400 years it would be included. Never the less it is still off by 26 seconds per year and even that changes. It comes out the United States weather service periodically adds a tiny fraction of a second to the calendar to keep our GPS systems functioning.

Both calendars require calculation and observation. The dates of the solstices can be mathematically derived. However lack of precision and lack of knowledge of science require periodic observation to get it right. Before the Great Flood the ancients constructed rooms with very narrow windows that only allowed the sun to directly shine in them on the days of astronomical importance. Calculation of the time of the new moon also runs into the same problems, and in the days of the Sanhedrin they required witnesses to testify they had seen moonless night. In fact both calendars are off when it comes to the position of the stars. For example the summer solstice now occurs when sun is in the constellation Gemini, not Cancer as it did 2000 years ago.

The Jewish calendar needs more tinkering. A little less then every three years an extra month is added. In addition to make life easier for the Jews, a day can be added or deleted so Yom Kippur and the fast of the Ninth of Av will not fall next to Shabbos. When the first Temple stood, the righteous King Hezekiah invited the nation to come to Jerusalem to celebrate Passover. It was the first time in many years that someone had inspired the people. To give the cohanim time to undergo ritual purification and the children of Israel adequate time to make the journey, he added a second Nissan to the calendar in which Pesach would be observed. The sages, though, did not thank him for this.

It comes out that the message of Shabbos Hahodesh is that we should live in harmony with nature but not be a slave to it. At times it is appropriate to be a little unscientific to make our lives more pleasant and meaningful. So too it is with our relationship with the environment, G-d, and our fellow man.



לע"נ ה אמה מלכה בת חיים ז"ל נלב"ע טז בנוסן תשנ"ח
העלון ניתן לקבל בדואר אלקטרוני  וגם באתר  http://dyschreiber.blogspot.co.il





YouTube              https://youtu.be/HJNCnd8_mZ0

No comments:

Post a Comment